Who speaks for you?

4 Dec

Embedded image permalink

I saw this quote today via @anon_online on Twitter it crystallised some thoughts I have been meditating on regarding who speaks for me.

I tend to be to the ‘left’ politically but what does that mean exactly? Is it the same definition as yours? I don’t belong to a political party as none of them accurately represent me.  When they speak it is not with my voice.  There has been a lot in MSM lately painting Russell Brand as the public voice of anon and the left.  Others have blogged on this @Maxjfreeman has an excellent post.   Leaving aside my feelings on Russell the person does he speak for me like they portray?  NO!

There are many positive reasons for banding together with or aligning oneself with a group of similar thinkers, I always espouse awareness of our collective consciousness and connectivity BUT and it is a big but (yes I have seen it in the mirror)  I refuse to have any person or organisation speak for me: with me yes.  That is an entirely different thing.

I don’t have the right to speak for anyone else unless they have specifically asked me and for good reason feel that they cannot use their own voice (I’m thinking about professions with restrictions) and I do not wish anyone to assume that they speak for me unless I have asked them, or for any media outlet or group of people to grab a hold of a figurehead and assume that because there are some similarities in our opinions that my voice is being heard simultaneously.  I try very hard not to do this for others and I want that reciprocated.

Having said all that, I feel that not speaking out and then proactively DOING something about the beliefs I hold makes me complicit in the charade, if I don’t speak up then I am allowing this misconception to continue.   This holds true for all behaviours.

Opinion: a view or judgement formed about something, not necessarily based on fact or knowledge.
Opinionated: arrogant assertiveness and dogmatism.
I wonder how many people can tell the difference between the noun and the adjective?  I’m not sure that I always do! 😉
Thanks @brianredfern for reminding me of this track!
Namaste  Jules

9 Responses to “Who speaks for you?”

  1. traveller47 Dec 4, 2014 at 1:07 pm #

    I agree to a degree with what you are saying. Being ConDemLaboural myself, I can’t understand why in this day and age rightism and leftism isn’t a thing of the past. Also, acting as a devils advocate I have to ask you, if you do not want anybody to speak for you, who will govern?

    • traveller47 Dec 4, 2014 at 1:08 pm #

      PS: Love the music 🙂

    • julieanneda Dec 4, 2014 at 1:10 pm #

      I was not thinking about governance as I wrote: more about popularist spokespeople whom have been seized upon for various reasons ☺

  2. traveller47 Dec 4, 2014 at 1:40 pm #

    It’s times like these that social media frustrates me. So much to ask and so much to say that just putting it down here doesn’t get the messages across. I’m not sure if I’m going off on a tangent here, but I just listened to a Russel Brand interview to try to get a better understanding of your blogg. Whether you agree with him or not, I believe we need more people like him to speak up and hasten the changes needed in the antiquated thinking of the British system. Not living in the UK, I’m not sure how RB is portrayed in the press but Evan Davis of BBC Newsnight gave him a fair hearing, I thought. Are you saying you don’t want him or people like him to voice an opinion on your behalf? If that’s the case, how will you voice your opinion?

    • julieanneda Dec 4, 2014 at 2:12 pm #

      I must not have been clear in expressing my thoughts: I have no animosity to RB, I like his ability to speak HIS views how HE sees them. What I am objecting to is the MSM pushing him as the alternative spokesperson for the left. He is not. He is one of many people who speak out/up. He is not my voice. That’s all. It’s about assumptions being peddled as facts.

    • julieanneda Dec 4, 2014 at 2:16 pm #

      I voice my opinion here and by my actions, on many occasions I join with others to make our voices a choir of protest. It is an active choice not a default choice or one that a newspaper has decided to make for me.

      • traveller47 Dec 4, 2014 at 6:36 pm #

        Yes, starting to undestand. Thats why I say I needed more than a few sentences. It’s the sort of thing one needs to sit down and discuss thoroughly in order to understand the others point of view.

  3. Dave Hasney Dec 12, 2014 at 1:20 pm #

    Reblogged this on Dave's Bankside Babble and commented:
    Never assume that someone who uses similar words to you actually thinks the same way you do…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

London Cottage Garden

Blogging about cottage garden style in a town garden


Ian Rotherham's Blog

Glebe House Garden

My week to week gardening diary

Life on both sides of the cell door

The story of my time working for HMP and then becoming a prisoner

Slavery was bad, okay?

These are the sorts of conversations I'm having in the 21st century. So I'm writing some of them down here for you.

Nathan Lee Davies

Author, poet, blogger and disabled activist

secular detective

Attempting a rational exploration of the issues of our time

Katyboo1's Weblog

The random jottings of a woman called Katy

The Heritage Journal

The Journal has been maintained since March 2005 to promote awareness and the conservation of the incomparable but often-threatened prehistoric sites of Britain, Ireland and beyond.

Stop UK lies & corruption

Can you afford not to see what your leaders are up to?

Expat In Bacolod

Stephen Bentley - Writer

Nick Lyall Raptor PPDG

Blogs from the Chair of the National Raptor Persecution PDG

TIm Lott's Writing Blog

Thoughts on writing fiction and being around on the planet

Bramble Garden

Country gardener nurturing people, plants - and wildlife


The strong tree bends and does not break--Laozi

F Yeah History

History...but better


Mainly a blog site about the rights and wrongs of Policing. Mainly.

Lothar Birkner

the author Lothar Birkner writes about literature and current topics

Robin M. Eames

poet, historian

Belfast Child

Remembering the Victims

The Chi Gardener

Channelling my chi energy, through the power of plants.


The Culture Of Now


Breaking News, Sports, Entertainment & Shopping

The Mindful Gardener

The sensory pleasures and earthy delights of gardening.

Ed Mayo's Blog

the power of co-operation

adrenalin ghosts

dreams and thoughts

Read After Burnout

Adventures in Everyday Madness Continuing

Duckweed Gardening

Sustainable backyard production of duckweed for feed, fuel, and fertilizer

Wetlands Steve

heritage and wildlife engagement.

Morgan S. Ray

Breaking The Rules

EDS and Chronic Pain News & Info

Curated News and Information on Chronic Pain and Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome


Reshaping Our Democracy

Dramatic Debi

“Who in the world am I? Ah, that's the great puzzle.” ― Lewis Carroll, Alice in Wonderland


My family and friends living with me.....and chronic illness


A disabled insomniac who crafts!!!!


The pretty good books of Susan Larson

There are still battles to be fought

A periodic blog on matters health, union, social justice, and the occasional random rant


Where discussion starts.....


Discovering we don't think inside the box or outside the box. We don't even know where the box is

Discordant Daydream

A vent of life's problems and delights

Grenfell Action Group

Working to defend and serve the Lancaster West community

%d bloggers like this: