Water Cannon in London

18 Feb

wolfinsheep

Yesterday I went to the Public Engagement Event on the possibility of the Metropolitan Police purchasing Water Cannon.  The event was very well attended by a variety of people of all different ages, cultures and societal groupings.  Nine people were given the opportunity to ask questions.  You can see the event here:

http://www.london.gov.uk/mayor-assembly/mayor/webcasts

I am not going to report on what was said there, apart from the fact no voice spoke in favour of water cannon apart from Mark Rowley the Senior Met Officer who presented the meeting and Stephen Greenhalgh the Deputy Mayor. This may have been due to the overwhelming *against* views that were very vocal and passionate.

I have always understood that the Police were policing by consent. It appeared from what was being said, and how it was being said that the decision TO purchase the Water Cannon had already been made and that the meeting was just part of a box ticking exercise. I hope that that is not the case, it was certainly the strongest perception that came across to me.

I would really like to know where the idea originated. Was it a political one via government, worried about the effects their austerity measures are having on the populace or was it from the Met? This makes a difference to me. If it is from the gvt then it actually gives me a glimmer of hope in the sense it shows that they realise the garden is not as rosy as they would like us to believe. If it came from the Met it grieves me more.

By saying that Water Cannon are needed the Met are saying to the people of London that all their attempts to engage with communities over the years has been wasted; they have lost control and have neither the numbers or the will to police protests without the assumption that mass civil unrest will follow on.

We were told that the Met want them as backup, a kind of insurance policy that they can deploy if needed. We were told that they recognised that the presence of Water Cannon on the streets could be inflammatory so they would be out of sight. I may be naive but I think three large trucks are going to be pretty hard to disguise, even if they put flowers in the nozzles and pretend they are planters.

I am disgusted by the thought that I may be at a lawful protest and have to walk past a water cannon truck somewhere. It would symbolise to me that those who are there are expected to behave in the worst way possible. By it’s presence I would feel my democratic rights were being threatened. It is a tool to create fear. It is a tool that is used in other countries to suppress legitimate protest. How could anyone think this is a good image to give to the rest of the world or our own citizens? If they were off in the backstreets social media and mobile phone communications would pass this information on quickly. What would this do in the psyche of the protestors? Would it make them feel they had stood up and shown what they believe in or would it inflame them to react? Would the police seek injunctions to jam signals so communications would not be able to be passed on?

What is this sounding like to you? It sounds like intimidation and suppression to me.

I truly am not trying to trivialise the safety of officers or other members of the public. They are deserving of protection. I am saying how gut wrenchingly close to feeling like a dictatorship this move would make me feel. I am old, I have protested about issues I believed in since I was a teen. If I was a young person with little hope what would I have to gain by behaving in a compliant way? What would I have to loose by behaving as dissaffected as I felt?

What ever your view, rushing the purchase through by the summer tells me the Met is scared.
I suspect that it will come to pass this summer.
Tragic… it will cause tragedy.
Liars promises

Advertisements

4 Responses to “Water Cannon in London”

  1. Stephen Grinstead (@HumGrin) February 19, 2014 at 9:17 am #

    Julie I think you are making a good point. Last year when I watched the “riots” in London on TV (and I use that word on purpose, because I believe that’s what they were) I immediately thought bring out the “water cannon” to stop the looting and violence. But when I sit down and quietly think about it, water cannons are the slippery slope to a police state or dictatorships, harsh words but non the less true; just look at many other countries around the world who use similar crowd control methods.
    Instead of finding ways to control the populace, government should be finding ways to get in touch with it’s citizens, not just by making some popularist decisions but bringing itself into the 21st century and aiming at giving the populace hope and light at the end of the tunnel.

    Leonid Breshnev in the 1960’s said “British democracy is an iron fist with a silk glove on”. At the time I laughed at his expression, but now I understand what he meant and agree 100% with him.

    We, the people have the “right” and indeed the “duty” under our freedom of speech and our human rights to make our opinions known by any peaceful way we want to and any government denying that is not a democratic government but Autocratic!

    • julieanneda February 19, 2014 at 9:20 am #

      Exactly that Stephen, exactly that xx

    • John Wood March 23, 2014 at 6:59 pm #

      My experience from 70-72 in NI convinced me that water cannon are a waste of time. They were never deployed until things got serious and the ‘targets’ were too fired up to be deterred by a jet of water. They are capable of breaking bones. They do not judge whether they hit me – doing no wrong – or the fire bomb bowler next to me. Useful agitprop was generated when risk of ppl being drowned was raised. These sort of claims meant that Elfn demanded a set of rigid rules as to when, where, and how was instituted. A practical point was access to places where water tanks could be refilled. It was not uncommon for canon to be away from scenes of rioting for long periods of time. They needed escorting there, while there and on the way back We did try using dye and then following up the stained ones for process. Ha! I equate them with Trident – look nice, do not work and cost too much. The real answer is a very strong force applying wooden poultice, identifying ring leaders and ‘snatching’ them. The media love photographing that sort of thing – think Orgreav & miner strike

      • julieanneda March 23, 2014 at 7:03 pm #

        I have heard a different tale from a friend in NI police who said w/cannon saved him several times from being a hogroast. I hope we have moved on from Orgreav. Good practical points raised. I tend to be emotive!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Grenfell Action Group

Working to defend and serve the Lancaster West community

gardeninacity

Notes from a wildlife-friendly cottage garden

Vox Political

politics for the people

Destined2Roam

Life is 10% what happens to us and 90% how we react to it

analiensaturn

the daily planet,

nodighome

no dig gardening, seasonal cooking, permaculture, preserving, foraging, storing, crafting, home life

Digging Deep

The Green Prescription Allotment

Disappointed Idealist

Ranting from the chalkface

Wildlife & Eco Gardens

Bringing nature to life

Dogwooddays

Life and the Garden

This little life of mine.

Living the nightmare with a smile on my face.

ALT-POLITICS

Politics For The People

rogerfrancis

Changing Lives Through Learning

Bert Fulks

Fall. Surrender. Restore. Rise. Repeat.

@PoliceGuvnor - The realities of policing

Follow me on Twitter or Facebook @PoliceGuvnor

Stop Deforestation

Deforestation. Endangered Species.

Graham Wettone

Policing Commentator

The Patchwork Banana

life, love, nature, musings

Square Cop In A Round World

A former cop taking on tough subjects

In Saner Thought

"It is the duty of every man, as far as his ability extends, to detect and expose delusion and error"..Thomas Paine

Cops Against

Find Your Voice

The Secret Barrister

Independent Blogger of the Year, The Comment Awards 2016

Burn Punk London

Just another WordPress.com site

ianchisnall

My views on current issues

F.I.N.E.

Fucked In-pain Neurotic etc

The Hippy Geek

One woman's experience of balancing nature and nerd.

The Militant Negro™

Poetry. Politics. Food. Art. Thoughts. Ideas. Opinions. Facts. Truth.

Depressed Detective

30 Year old UK Police Detective, with some Depression, Anxiety and Insomnia issues.

BSC Policing Network

Connecting Policing Researchers In The UK And Beyond

Gem's Things

My Things: stuff I've bought, things I've done, food I've eaten and places I've stayed.

Dave Throup

Environment Agency Manager for Herefordshire and Worcestershire

finnmackay

Feminist activist & researcher.

prisonscrew

Just another WordPress.com site

Britain Isn't Eating

The Tory Govn, killing the unemployed, the poor, vulnerable, sick & disabled since 2010.

Ex-PTSD Detective

Retired after thirty years in police. Will dedicate my time to assist all those suffering with PTSD. Will continue to expose the corruption that exists in British policing

SPeye Joe (Welfarewrites)

Joe Halewood writes about tenant and welfare wrongs

Walk a Mile in My Shoes

A walk around the edge of the UK making a noise about mental health

Badge415

The Human Side of Police Work

%d bloggers like this: